One of our assistants had a birthday last week and we wanted to break with the usual Buttercup Bakery cupcakes tradition our office has (which is cool, cause I think they’re gross). Matt told us about her love of cheesecake, but we were stunned to find out that the 3″ cheesecakes from Billy’s Bakery are $4.50 each! For more than a dollar an inch, I’m sure it’s f***ing delicious, but that’s just excessive.
I’d made mini cheesecakes for my craft group last winter, and knew that I could crank out two dozen for under twenty bucks. Of course, that meant I’d be baking cheesecakes at 12:30 am, but that never bothers me until I’m so tired my eyes are crossing and I realize I have to wait another half hour to take them out of the oven. Meh.
The other challenge was not reallllllllly a challenge because I half assed it, but I used Pamela’s wheat-free and gluten-free cookies as the crust so that one of our colleagues could partake. Having celiacs means she’s always getting shafted on the office treats, which makes me feel sad. I substituted Pamela’s Shortbread Cookies and Ginger Cookies for the graham cracker or oreo cookie base that I’d normally use for the crust, and they came out pretty well. They’re very soft right out of the package - if I do this again I’ll try letting them sit out for a day to get a little dry/stale and hopefully make them more crumbly. Making wheat/gluten free cake flour is a whole ‘nother monster that will require stocking up on all kinds of ingredients I don’t normally have (xanthan gum, rice flour) but I will give it a go on another occasion!
The fatigue meant that I kind of spaced on taking pictures, but here’s a shot of the cheesecakes going into a tiffin to be brought to the office - they were definitely a hit! I forgot to leave a few at home for my cheesecake-loving mister, so I think I’m going to have to do another batch this weekend. Tragic, I know….

Italian-style Mini Cheesecakes:
(using cupcake tins, makes about 2 dozen)
Mix:
1 cup crushed oreos, graham crackers, etc…
2 T melted butter
into a crumble and press into the bottom of a greased cupcake tin (I have ones that make 12 at a time, which is ideal for this recipe)
Combine:
4 eggs
8 oz cream cheese
1 cup ricotta
1 cup sugar
Here I also like to add some combination of: orange or lemon zest, vanilla extract, ground ginger - get creative!
Pour the mixture into the muffin tins and bake at 350 for about 30 minutes, til the edges get golden brown. If you’re going to add a fruit or chocolate chip topping, toss them on 5-10 minutes before the cheesecakes come out of the oven. I don’t rock that gross pie filling action. Fresh fruit, baby. Or, if there’s time, the compote recipe that’s posted below would be good.
Let them cool completely on a wire rack. Let. them. cool. completely. Then refrigerate for 10 minutes. THEN pop them out of the tin. Do not be like me and deliriously decide that you absolutely positively MUST GO TO BED that very moment and try to extract them before they’re cool and break the crust into a bajillion pieces. You will convince yourself that you’ve ruined Aryanna’s 29th birthday and sleep like crap and be very cranky when you have to wake up early for a doctor’s appointment. Or maybe that’s just me.
Question for you….how do you cook your cheesecake? These end up very dense, and don’t taste like traditional New York cheesecake since they’re more Italian style and rely on the ricotta more than the cream cheese for flavor. If I were making regular cheesecake, I’d do it in a springform pan and/or a warm water bath. Haven’t thought about trying it with these. Do you find that one way works better than the other?
I know this is a rhetorical question since we don’t yet get many comments but I thought I’d try…..